Craik & Tulving (1975) Levels of Processing



Introduction

Craik & Tulving wanted to test whether the level of processing affected how well we remember information. By "depth of processing", we mean, the way in which a person thinks about a piece of information, for example, a shallow level of processing of a word would be to skim over a sentence and to understand the sentence without dwelling on the individual word. In this way, we have processed the meaning of the word, but only in order to understand the sentence. A deeper level of processing, on the other hand, would be to look at the word by itself, outside of a sentence, and to think of what the word means; maybe even what other words rhyme with it. This way, we are also more likely to remember it.

How Craik & Tulving set out to test level of processing

In 1975, the researchers conducted an experiment in which participants were shown a list of 60 words.

They were then asked to recall certain words by being shown one of three questions, each testing a different level of processing, similar to:

  • Was the word in capital letters or lower case? (Tests structural processing SHALLOW PROCESSING)
  • Does the word rhyme with (another word)? (Tests phonemic/auditory processing, as the participant has to listen to the word judge whether it rhymes with another word)
  • Does the word fit in the following sentence...? (Tests semantic processing; understanding the meaning of the word DEEP PROCESSING/ ELABORATE REHEARSAL)

Out of another larger list, the participants were asked to pick out the appropriate word, as the original words had been mixed into this list.

Findings

Craik & Tulving found that participants were better able to recall words which had been processed more deeply - that is, processed semantically, supporting level of processing theory.

Evaluation of this experiment

Craik and Tulving's research supports their level of processing theory.

As deeper processing would logically take more time to execute than shallow processing (e.g. thinking of words that rhyme with a word vs. noticing whether a word is capitalized), it is unclear whether time taken to process, or level of processing is the actual cause of recall.

Craik & Tulving's experiment lacks a degree of ecological validity in that only word recall is tested. In reality whereas structural and visual processing might be expected to higher if a person had been asked to recall a picture they had seen, for example.

More on Craik & Lockhart's Levels of Processing theory is available here

 

More Memory Theories:

Multi-Store Model: A popular explanation of how we remember. Multi-Store Model

Miller's Magic Number: How many chunks of information can our memories store? Magic Number

Working Memory Model: Do our memories work to process information? Working Memory Model

Forgetting & Recall: A look at how psychologists think information can be 'forgotten' and retrieved

Memory Decay (Peterson & Peterson, 1959): How fast does our Short-term Memory Decay?

 

Memory Improvement Techniques

Remember lists of information: Use the Luria method and convert lists to journeys. Read more...

Memorizing phone numbers: Discover this popular mnemonics technique: the Pegword Method

Need to remember anything else? The Retentive Method is a powerful method.

More Articles, Techniques & Tests on Memory Psychology...




Sign Up for Full Access

Access hundreds of theories, approaches, study and experiment overviews, plus a range of psychology guides including Body Language Reading and How to Interpret Your Dreams.

Sign Up Today ›


 More on Memory Psychology

Memory Like A Goldfish?

Test your short-term memory with this online feature.

Memory Test ›


Chew For Memory?

How research at two universities found memory recall can be improved by chewing...

"It Happened In A Flash"

Flashbulb memories explained. Includes characteristics of flashbulb memories,...

Magic Number Seven

Miller (1956): How many pieces of information can you remember? Miller's Magic...

Why Do We Forget?

Why do we forget? Find out in this fascinating article.

Conditioned Behavior

What is conditioning? What Pavlov's dogs experiment teaches us about how we...


More on Memory Psychology  

Sign Up for Full Access

Join Psychologist World today for access to our entire 2,200+ collection of psychology theories, approaches, studies, experiments and online guides.

  • Psychology approaches, theories and studies explained
  • Body Language Reading Guide
  • How to Interpret Your Dreams Guide
  • Self Hypnosis Downloads
  • Plus More Member Benefits

Learn More and Sign Up ›


Psychologist World is an online magazine dedicated to psychology, providing theory and experiment overviews, popular psychology articles and practical psychology guides. For details of content available with membership click here.